Superintendent churn comes with a cost for students

kAmu:7E66? J62CD 28@[ E96 492==6?86 @7 =625:?8 E96 r@>AE@? &?:7:65 $49@@= s:DEC:4E H@F=5 92G6 D42C65 @77 6G6? E96 >@DE 4@?7:56?E 65F42E:@? =6256C] s2C:? qC2H=6J 2=>@DE A2DD65 :E @G6C]k^Am

kAm%96 FC32? DJDE6>[ ;FDE @77 @?6 @7 {@D p?86=6D’ >2;@C 7C66H2JD[ H2D 962565 7@C DE2E6 E2<6@G6C 2?5 925 2 dgT 8C25F2E:@? C2E6] (96? E96 @A6?:?8 H2D A@DE65[ “x E9@F89E[ ‘r@>AE@?[ x 5@?’E H2?E E@ 36 :? r@>AE@?[’” qC2H=6J E@=5 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]E96fc>:==:@?]@C8Qm%96 fck^2m]k^Am

kAmqFE qC2H=6J D2H 2 “A@4<6E @7 DF446DD” 2E D@>6 6=6>6?E2CJ D49@@=D E92E 96 4@F=5 3F:=5 @?] p446AE:?8 E96 ;@3 :? a_`a[ 96 :?DE:EFE65 2 D6E @7 C@FE:?6D[ =:<6 :?\D49@@= EFE@C:?8 2?5 7C6BF6?E >F=E:A=:42E:@? AC24E:46] (66<=J BF:KK6D =6E E62496CD <?@H AC64:D6=J H9:49 DEF56?ED ?665 6IEC2 96=A]k^Am

kAmu@FCE66? J62CD =2E6C[ E96 5:DEC:4E[ H:E9 2 h`T A@G6CEJ C2E6[ :D @?6 @7 E96 ?2E:@?’D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^65F42E:@?D4@C642C5]@C8^HA\4@?E6?E^FA=@25D^a_ae^_d^rp0r@>AE@?\&?:7:65\$49@@=\s:DEC:4E0a_ad\&A52E6]A57Qm72DE6DE\:>AC@G:?8k^2m]k^Am

kAm“x7 J@F 8@ 324< `d[ a_ J62CD 28@[ r@>AE@? H2D ?@E E96 A=246 H96C6 >@DE A2C6?ED H@F=5 92G6 <6AE E96:C <:5D[” 96 D2:5] x? 724E[ :E H2D E96 7:CDE 5:DEC:4E :? r2=:7@C?:2 H96C6 72>:=:6D EC:65 E@ 4@?G6CE 2 =@H\A6C7@C>:?8 6=6>6?E2CJ D49@@= :?E@ 2 492CE6C F?56C 2 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]H2D9:?8E@?A@DE]4@>^?2E:@?2=^A2C6?E\EC:886C\D49@@=\E6DED\42=:7@C?:2\=2H\E92E\2==@HD\E2<6@G6C\G:2\A6E:E:@?^a_`a^_a^ab^8x"p=h8*E#0DE@CJ]9E>=QmDE2E6 “A2C6?E EC:886C” =2Hk^2m] “}@H[ H6 D66 2 C6G6CD2=]”k^Am

kAm%96 5:DEC:4E :D 2=D@ @?6 @7 @?=J fg[ @FE @7 E96 ?2E:@?’D d__ =2C86DE[ E92E 92D >2:?E2:?65 4@?D:DE6?E =6256CD9:A 2E E96 E@A D:?46 E96 A2?56>:4[ 244@C5:?8 E@ 2 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]:=@8C@FA]4@>^?6HD^E@Ad__\D6AE6>36C\a_ae^Qm?6H 2?2=JD:Dk^2m 7C@> x{~ vC@FA[ 2 4@?DF=E:?8 7:C>] pE E96 DE2E6 =6G6=[ 2== 3FE D6G6? 92G6 492?865 65F42E:@? 49:67D 2E =62DE @?46[ H:E9 >@C6 EFC?@G6C 4@>:?8 @?46 ?6H 8@G6C?@CD E2<6 @77:46 ?6IE J62C]k^Am

kAmpD :? r@>AE@?[ x{~’D 52E2 D9@HD[ DEF56?ED 2C6 36EE6C @77 H96? 5:DEC:4E =6256CD DE2J =@?86C]k^Am

kAmx? E9@D6 H:E9 ?@ =6256CD9:A 492?86D 36EH66? a_`h 2?5 a_ad[ <:5D A6C7@C>65 36EE6C :? C625:?8 2?5 >2E9 — D9@H:?8 2E =62DE 2 >@?E9 @7 6IEC2 =62C?:?8 — E92? E9@D6 :? 5:DEC:4ED H:E9 EFC?@G6C] x? H@>6?\=65 5:DEC:4ED[ E96 25G2?E286 H2D ?62C=J EH@ 6IEC2 >@?E9D @7 =62C?:?8 :? >2E9[ 32D65 @? E96 $E2?7@C5 t5F42E:@? s2E2 pC49:G6[ 2 4@>A2C23=6 >62DFC6 @7 DEF56?E =62C?:?8 24C@DD DE2E6D] k^Am

k7:8FC6mk:>8 DC4lQ9EEADi^^:>286D]DE24<6C]4@>^H^`ag_^:>286D^DE@C:6D^a_ae^`_^b_^DFA6\EFC?@G6C]A?8Q 2=ElQr92CE D9@H:?8 E92E DEF56?ED :? 5:DEC:4ED H:E9 >@C6 DE23:=:EJ 56>@?DEC2E65 2E =62DE 2 >@?E9 6IEC2 @7 =62C?:?8 E92? E9@D6 H:E9 EFC?@G6C] (@>6?\=65 5:DEC:4ED A6C7@C>65 6G6? 36EE6C]Q DEJ=6lQH:5E9i `__TQ ^mk7:842AE:@?mx{~ vC@FAk^7:842AE:@?mk^7:8FC6m

kAm“$E23:=:EJ C62==J >2EE6CD H:E9:? 2 4@>>F?:EJ[” D2:5 yF=:2 #272=\q26C[ E96 x{~ vC@FA’D rt~] x? E9@D6 H:E9 9:89 EFC?@G6C[ E96 <:5D H9@ H6C6 :? <:?56C82CE6? 2E E96 DE2CE @7 E96 A2?56>:4 92G6 =:<6=J D66? >F=E:A=6 C625:?8 AC@8C2>D “@C E96:C A2C6?ED H6C6 2D<65 E@ DE2CE @?6 >@C6 DEC2E68:4 A=2??:?8 AC@46DD] xE 86ED @=5]”k^Am

kAm~E96C 5:DEC:4ED :? E96 E@A d__[ D@>6E:>6D 6>3C@:=65 :? 4@?EC@G6CDJ[ 92G6 6IA6C:6?465 >F=E:A=6 =6256CD9:A 492?86D D:?46 E96 A2?56>:4] k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]2E=2?E2?6HD7:CDE]4@>^a_ad^`_^`_^DFA6C:?E6?56?ED\:?5:4E>6?E\@?=J\=2E6DE\FA962G2=\56<2=3\D49@@=\DJDE6>^Qms6z2=3 r@F?EJ[ v6@C8:2k^2m[ 7@C 6I2>A=6[ :D @? :ED 7@FCE9 49:67 D:?46 a_a_] u@C>6C $FA6C:?E6?56?E s6G@? w@CE@? H2D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]HD3EG]4@>^?6HD^=@42=^7@C>6C\56<2=3\DFA6C:?E6?56?E\:?5:4E65\2DD2F=E\49:=5\4CF6=EJ\492C86D^+r+b%)y|cqru+tsa"y*dss|d!t^Qm:?5:4E65 :? pF8FDEk^2m @? 492C86D E92E 96 2DD2F=E65 9:D H:76 :? 7C@?E @7 9:D EH@ 49:=5C6?] k^Am

kAm%96 t2DE q2E@? #@F86 5:DEC:4E :? {@F:D:2?2 :D 2=D@ @? :ED 7@FCE9 DFA6C:?E6?56?E D:?46 a_a_[ H:E9 4FCC6?E =6256C {2>@?E r@=6 724:?8 492C86D 7@C 3C:36CJ 2?5 >@?6J =2F?56C:?8 DE6>>:?8 7C@> 9:D E:>6 2D 2 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]H273]4@>^a_ae^_g^ad^:\E62>\=2>@?E\4@=6\3C62<D\D:=6?46\3C:36CJ\:?5:4E>6?E^Qm4:EJ 4@F?4:=>2?k^2m] w6 56?:6D E96 244FD2E:@?D[ 2?5 3@2C5 >6>36CD D2J E96J DFAA@CE 9:>] qFE E96J’G6 2=D@ E:89E6?65 FA k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]J29@@]4@>^?6HD^A@=:E:4D^2CE:4=6D^63C\D49@@=\3@2C5\E:89E6?D\@G6CD:89E\`ebcb`fgg]9E>=Qm@G6CD:89E @7 4@?EC24EDk^2m] k^Am

kAm~G6C2==[ x{~’D =2E6DE C6G:6H D9@HD E92E 49FC? :D 5@H? 7@C E96 7:CDE E:>6 D:?46 E96 A2?56>:4] {2DE J62C[ :E 2AA62C65 E92E 5:DEC:4ED 925 C624965 2 “?6H ?@C>2=[” H:E9 EFC?@G6C C2?8:?8 7C@> a_T E@ abT 7@C 7:G6 J62CD DEC2:89E] qFE E9:D J62C[ 2>@?8 E96 E@A d__[ :E 92D 5C@AA65 E@ `fT[ H9:49 :D 4=@D6C E@ E96 EJA:42= AC6\r~'xs =6G6=D @7 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]22D2]@C8^C6D@FC46D^C6D@FC46^2C6\H6\3FC?65\@FE\2\>F=E:\J62C\DE2E6H:56\DEF5J\@7\A\`a\DFA6C:?E6?56?EDQm`cT E@ `eTk^2m C6A@CE65 3J pp$p[ E96 $49@@= $FA6C:?E6?56?ED pDD@4:2E:@?]k^Am

kAm#272=\q26C 42FE:@?65 E92E H9:=6 E96 “42C@FD6= @7 =6256CD9:A D66>D E@ 92G6 D=@H65 5@H?[” E96 C6DF=ED 2C6 ;FDE 2 D?2AD9@E] “%9:D :D?’E 2 C6EFC? E@ ?@C>2= D@ >F49 2D E96 DJDE6> 7:?2==J 42E49:?8 :ED 3C62E9]”k^Am

kAm%96 564=:?6 :? EFC?@G6C[ D96 25565[ 4@F=5 A@:?E E@ E96 4FCC6?E 7:?2?4:2= 4@?DEC2:?ED @? 5:DEC:4ED 2D E96J 25;FDE E@ E96 6?5 @7 7656C2= C6=:67 7F?5D 2?5 @?8@:?8 564=:?6D :? 6?C@==>6?E]k^Am

kAm“%96D6 D62C496D 2C6 G6CJ 6IA6?D:G6[” D96 D2:5] p k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]>2:?DEC66E52:=J?6HD]4@>^65F42E:@?^2=249F2\4@F?EJ\>4A96CD@?\;24@3D@?\DFA6C:?E6?56?E\D62C49Qmu=@C:52 5:DEC:4Ek^2m C646?E=J DA6?E 23@FE Scg[___ E@ 7:?5 2 ?6H =6256C[ H9:=6 E96 r=2C< r@F?EJ 5:DEC:4E’D D62C49 :? a_ac k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^?6HDb=G]4@>^?6HD^=@42=^9@H\>F49\:D\44D5\A2J:?8\D62C49\7:C>\E@\7:?5\?6H\DFA6C:?E6?56?EQm6I466565 S`__[___k^2m] “%96C6 >2J 36 =6DD @7 2 56D:C6 E@ E6== J@FC 4@>>F?:EJ[ H96? J@F’C6 4FEE:?8 2DD:DE2?E AC:?4:A2=D[ E92E J@F’C6 ?@H 8@:?8 E@ DA6?5 >@?6J @? 2 D62C49 7:C>]” k^Am

k9bmp ‘7=2D9A@:?E’k^9bm

kAm#2496= (9:E6[ 2? 2DD@4:2E6 AC@76DD@C 2E E96 &?:G6CD:EJ @7 %6I2D 2E pFDE:?[ 2?5 7@F?56C @7 2 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^E96DFA6C:?E6?56?E=23]4@>QmC6D62C49 46?E6Ck^2m @? D49@@= DFA6C:?E6?56?ED[ DF886DE65 E96 A2?56>:4 J62CD H6C6 2? 2?@>2=J] $49@@= 3@2C5 7:89ED @G6C r~'xs\C6=2E65 4=@DFC6D[ >2D<D 2?5 4F=EFC6 H2C :DDF6D “H6C6 @3G:@FD=J BF:E6 G@=2E:=6[” D96 D2:5[ 2?5 :? >F=E:A=6 5:DEC:4ED[ =65 E@ DFA6C:?E6?56?ED 36:?8 23CFAE=J 5:D>:DD65] k^Am

kAm%92E H2D “9@A67F==J 2 @?46\:?\2\=:76E:>6 7=2D9A@:?E[” D96 D2:5] “|2J36 D49@@= 3@2C5D … 2C6 =6DD =:<6=J E@ 5@ 2H2J H:E9 E96 DFA6C:?E6?56?E H9@ E96J 5:D28C66 H:E9 :56@=@8:42==J @? @?6 E9:?8]” k^Am

kAmw6C @H? C6D62C49 @? DFA6C:?E6?56?E EFC?@G6C 649@6D 4@??64E:@?D x{~ >256 36EH66? DEF56?E =62C?:?8 2?5 4@?D:DE6?E =6256CD9:A] (9:=6 DEF5:6D AC:@C E@ E96 A2?56>:4 D9@H65 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]3C@@<:?8D]65F^HA\4@?E6?E^FA=@25D^a_`e^_e^$FA6C:?E6?56?EDqC@H?\r6?E6Chb`c]A57Qm>:?:>2= :>A24Ek^2m @7 EFC?@G6C @? DEF56?E @FE4@>6D[ “49C@?:4 :?DE23:=:EJ” 42? 9:E ?665:6DE DEF56?ED E96 92C56DE[ (9:E6 D2:5] k^Am

kAmp44@C5:?8 E@ 2 ?6H k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^65H@C<:?8A2A6CD]4@>^D:E6D^5672F=E^7:=6D^2:ae\`dgd]A57QmA2A6Ck^2m[ D96 7@F?5 E92E DEF56?ED :? 9:89\A@G6CEJ 5:DEC:4ED H:E9 C6A62E65 =6256CD9:A EFC?@G6C H6C6 23@FE EH@ >@?E9D @7 =62C?:?8 369:?5 :? >2E9 2?5 D:I H66<D 369:?5 :? C625:?8 4@>A2C65 H:E9 E9@D6 :? DJDE6>D H:E9 E96 D2>6 =6256C D:?46 a_`h]k^Am

kAm{6256CD H9@ DE2J :? 2 5:DEC:4E =@?86C 2C6 >@C6 =:<6=J E@ EC2?D76C <?@H=6586 E9C@F89@FE E96 @C82?:K2E:@?[ D96 D2:5[ 2?5 @7E6? 3F:=5 FA ECFDE H:E9 E96 AF3=:4]k^Am

kAm“%96 =@?86C 2 DFA6C:?E6?56?E DE2JD[ E96 >@C6 A6@A=6 36=:6G6 E96J 2C6 4@>>:EE65 E@ E92E 4@>>F?:EJ[” D96 D2:5] “*@F 42? E2<6 D@>6 C:D<D] xE’D C62==J :>A@CE2?E E@ 36 23=6 E@ D2J[ ‘w6J[ E9:D >:89E ?@E H@C< @FE[ 3FE x E9:?< E96C6’D A@E6?E:2==J D@>6 C6EFC? @? :?G6DE>6?E 96C6]’ ” k^Am

kAm!@=:4J 6IA6CED =:<6 E@ E2=< 23@FE “5FC23=6” =62C?:?8 2?5 DF446DD 7@C D49@@=D] k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^E96?6IEb_J62CD]DF3DE24<]4@>^A^9@H\E@\9:C6\2\D49@@=\DFA6C:?E6?56?EQm#@36CE !@?5:D4:@k^2m[ 2 D6?:@C 76==@H 2E E96 4@?D6CG2E:G6 p>6C:42? t?E6CAC:D6 x?DE:EFE6[ D2JD E92E ?@E @?=J :D =6256CD9:A 49FC? “@?6 @7 E96 8C62E6DE E9C62ED E@ 5FC23:=:EJ[” 3FE E92E D49@@= 3@2C5D ?665 DFA6C:?E6?56?ED H9@ G:6H :?DECF4E:@? 2D E96 49:67 AC:@C:EJ[ ?@E ;FDE @?6 @7 >2?J :?:E:2E:G6D]k^Am

kAmqC2H=6J[ H9@ H2D 2 D4:6?46 E62496C 2?5 AC:?4:A2= :? @E96C 5:DEC:4ED 367@C6 >@G:?8 :?E@ =6256CD9:A[ 92D DF49 2 “DEC@?8 4@?G:4E:@?D” 23@FE :>AC@G:?8 >2E9 2?5 C625:?8[ (9:E6 D2:5[ E92E 96’D 366? 23=6 E@ <66A E96 5:DEC:4E >@G:?8 7@CH2C5 56DA:E6 @E96C A@=:E:42= :DDF6D E92E DFA6C:?E6?56?ED @7E6? ?2G:82E6] k^Am

kAm“%96C6’D 2 C62= 36=:67 E92E E96D6 DEF56?ED 2C6 3C:==:2?E 2?5 E96J ;FDE ?665 E96 C:89E C6D@FC46D 2?5 2 DE23=6 E62496C H@C<7@C46[” D96 D2:5] k^Am

kAmw:D >6E9@5D 2C6?’E A@AF=2C H:E9 6G6CJ@?6] %96 r@>AE@? E62496CD F?:@? AC6D:56?E 92D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^65D@FC46]@C8^a_ad^E@@\>F49\E6DE\AC6A\:?D:56\4@>AE@?\F?:7:65D\7C6BF6?E\2DD6DD>6?ED^fag_`hQmBF6DE:@?65 9:D :?E6?D6 7@4FDk^2m @? E6DE:?8] qFE r64:=:2 |4sF77:6[ AC:?4:A2= @7 u@DE6C t=6>6?E2CJ[ D2:5 E96 6>A92D:D @? 52E2[ 4@>3:?65 H:E9 AC24E:46D :>A=6>6?E65 2E 2== D49@@=D[ 92D 96=A65 96C DEF56?ED C:D6 7C@> E96 3@EE@>]k^Am

kAm~? 2 C646?E >@C?:?8[ 2 H66< 27E6C D49@@= DE2CE65[ u@DE6C DEF56?ED DA6?E E:>6 C6DA@?5:?8 E@ E96 HC:E:?8 AC@>AEi (92E 5@ J@F =:<6 23@FE J@FC E62496Cn {6256CD :?4C62D65 E96:C 7@4FD @? HC:E:?8 — 2?5 D:8?:7:42?E=J 4FE 324< @? D4C66? E:>6 —  27E6C @3D6CG:?8 E92E DEF56?ED 4@F=5?’E C642== H92E 925 366? E2F89E] k^Am

kAm“(6 <?@H E92E HC:E:?8 6=:4:ED 2 4@??64E:@?[” qC2H=6J D2:5] “x7 J@F 5@?’E HC:E6 :E 5@H?[ J@F’C6 ?@E C62==J =62C?:?8 :E]” k^Am

kAmu@DE6C H2D ?@E 2 “A@4<6E @7 DF446DD” H96? qC2H=6J 2CC:G65 :? r@>AE@?] x? a_`c[ =6DD E92? 2 BF2CE6C @7 DEF56?ED >6E @C 6I466565 DE2E6 DE2?52C5D :? C625:?8 2?5 >2E9] {2DE D49@@= J62C[ ffT @7 DEF56?ED D4@C65 E92E 9:89 :? E9@D6 DF3;64ED[ 2?5 fbT C624965 E92E =6G6= :? D4:6?46[ ?62C=J 9:EE:?8 E96 8@2= @7 fdT]k^Am

kAm|4sF77:6[ A:4EFC65 36=@H[  D2:5 E92E qC2H=6J 92D 4C62E65 DJDE6>D E92E H:== @FE=2DE 9:>]k^Am

kAm“x7 96 H6C6 E@ =62G6 E@>@CC@H[ x H@F=5 <?@H E92E x 2=H2JD ?665 E@ 92G6 2 A=2?] x ?665 E@ 2=H2JD C67:?6 >J A=2? 32D65 @? 52E2[” D96 D2:5] “p?5 x ?665 E@ DE2CE 2== >J :?E6CG6?E:@?D 62C=J] *@F 42?’E H2:E F?E:= |2C49]”k^Am

k7:8FC6mk:>8 DC4lQ9EEADi^^:>286D]DE24<6C]4@>^H^`ag_^:>286D^DE@C:6D^a_ae^`_^b_^464:=:2\DFA6\EFC?@G6C\`]A?8Q 2=ElQr646=:2 |4sF77:6[ AC:?4:A2= @7 u@DE6C t=6>6?E2CJ $49@@=[ H:E9 DEF56?ED :? 2 =F?49C@@>] $96 D2:5 DJDE6>D[ =:<6 2 5:DEC:4EH:56 7@4FD @? HC:E:?8 2?5 7C6BF6?E >F=E:A=:42E:@? AC24E:46[ 92D 96=A65 96C D49@@= 364@>6 @?6 @7 r@>AE@?UCDBF@jD 9:896DE A6C7@C>:?8]Q DEJ=6lQH:5E9i `__TQ ^mk7:842AE:@?m{:?52 y24@3D@? ^^ %96 fck^7:842AE:@?mk^7:8FC6m

kAm(9:=6 x{~’D 52E2 42AEFC6D E96 A2?56>:4 A6C:@5[ D@>6 5:DEC:4ED[ =:<6 qC:586A@CE[ r@??64E:4FE[ 92G6 6IA6C:6?465 7C6BF6?E EFC?@G6C 24C@DD 2 >F49 =@?86C A6C:@5] $:?46 a__d[ E96 5:DEC:4E 92D 925 6:89E DFA6C:?E6?56?ED[ 2?5 7@C>6C =6256C r2C>6=2 {6GJ\s2G:5 =67E :? =2E6 a_ac 27E6C 2 ?62C\F?2?:>@FD k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]HD9F]@C8^4@??64E:4FE\?6HD^a_ac\`_\ac^4E\3C:586A@CE\E62496CD\42C>6=2\=6GJ\52G:5Qm?@ 4@?7:56?46 G@E6k^2m 7C@> E96 E62496CD F?:@?] t249 EC2?D:E:@? “42CC:6D D@>6 4@DED[” D2:5 y@D6A9 $@<@=@G:4[ G:46\492:C @7 E96 3@2C5] k^Am

kAm“}6H =6256CD @7E6? 3C:?8 ?6H AC:@C:E:6D[ 2?5 5:776C6?E 2AAC@2496D E@ :>A=6>6?E E9@D6 AC:@C:E:6D[” 96 D2:5] “r@>>F?:EJ 2?5 3@2C5 C6=2E:@?D9:AD >FDE 36 C63F:=E] %CFDE >FDE 36 62C?65 282:?]”k^Am

kAmqFE 96 D2:5 :E’D :>A@CE2?E E@ AFE E96 :?DE23:=:EJ :? 4@?E6IE] %H@ EFC?@G6CD @44FCC65 H9:=6 E96 5:DEC:4E H2D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]492=<362E]@C8^A9:=256=A9:2^a_`b^f^a^aa`gba`e^6I\A9:==J\DFA6C:?E6?56?E\A2F=\G2==2D\@FDE65\2D\3C:586A@CE\D49@@=D\49:67^QmF?56C DE2E6 E2<6@G6Ck^2m] %96 5:DEC:4E 2=D@ 92D @?6 @7 E96 9:896DE\A@G6CEJ C2E6D :? E96 DE2E6[ 2?5 DA6?5D k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^D49@@=DE2E67:?2?46]@C8^:DDF6D^DA6?5:?8Qm=6DD A6C DEF56?Ek^2m E92? H62=E9:6C 5:DEC:4ED =:<6 vC66?H:49[ H9:49 92D D66? 6G6? k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]8C66?H:49E:>6]4@>^=@42=^2CE:4=6^up"\s@6D\vC66?H:49\92G6\2\C6G@=G:?8\5@@C\@7\`bfaahce]A9AQm>@C6 EFC?@G6Ck^2m :? E96 A2DE a_ J62CD] k^Am

kAm“}@ DFA6C:?E6?56?E[ C682C5=6DD @7 E2=6?E[ 42? 6=:>:?2E6 4@?46?EC2E65 A@G6CEJ @C 6C2D6 564256D @7 64@?@>:4 ?68=64E[” $@<@=@G:4 D2:5] (:E9 E96 5:DEC:4E 4FCC6?E=J 4@?5F4E:?8 2?@E96C D62C49[ 96 D2:5 E96 5:DEC:4E ?665D “2 =6256C H:==:?8 E@ 4@>>:E 7@C E96 =@?8 E6C>[ D@>6@?6 H9@ F?56CDE2?5D E96 4@>A=6I:E:6D @7 2? FC32? 5:DEC:4E 2?5 :D H:==:?8 E@ 4@?7C@?E 5:77:4F=E :DDF6D 5:C64E=J]”k^Am

k9bm‘#@FE6 E@ E96 DFA6C:?E6?56?4J’k^9bm

kAm$49@@= 3@2C5D D9@F=5 2=D@ =@@< 7@C :?DECF4E:@?2= 6IA6CE:D6[ D2:5 #272=\q26C]k^Am

kAmp H@>6?\@H?65 @C82?:K2E:@?[ x{~ vC@FA <66AD 4=@D6 EC24< @7 H96C6 H@>6? 2C6 364@>:?8 5:DEC:4E 49:67D 2?5 E96:C C@FE6D E@ E96 A@D:E:@?] k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^<2AA2?@?=:?6]@C8^>2C2?E@\42CC@==\496?8\E6@5@C@\D49@@=\=6256CD9:A\86?56C^Qm}2E:@?2= 52E2k^2m D9@HD E92E H@>6? 2C6 EH:46 2D =:<6=J 2D >6? E@ 92G6 2? 24256>:4 A@DE[ =:<6 4FCC:4F=F> DA64:2=:DE[ @? E96:C C6DF>6] qFE ;FDE 2 92?57F= @7 4FCC6?E DFA6C:?E6?56?ED 42>6 7C@> 2 A@D:E:@? =625:?8 4FCC:4F=F> 2?5 :?DECF4E:@?]k^Am

kAm“v:G6? H96C6 DEF56?E @FE4@>6D DE2?5 C:89E ?@H[ J@F H@F=5 6IA64E E96 24256>:4D D62E E@ 36 E96 DFC6DE C@FE6 E@ E96 DFA6C:?E6?56?4J] xE EFC?D @FE E@ 36 @?6 @7 E96 C2C6DE[” D96 D2:5] “q@2C5D <66A D2J:?8 :?DECF4E:@? :D E96 AC:@C:EJ] %96:C 9:C:?8 D2JD @E96CH:D6]”k^Am

k7:8FC6mk:>8 DC4lQ9EEADi^^:>286D]DE24<6C]4@>^H^`ag_^:>286D^DE@C:6D^a_ae^`_^b_^86?56C\3C62<5@H?\DFA6D]A?8Q 2=ElQq2C 492CE D9@H:?8 E92E 2>@?8 E96 E@A d__ 5:DEC:4ED :? E96 &]$] E96 A6C46?E286 @7 =6256CD H9@ 2C6 H@>6? :D FA E@ bcT]Q DEJ=6lQH:5E9i `__TQ ^mk7:842AE:@?mx{~ vC@FAk^7:842AE:@?mk^7:8FC6m

kAm~G6C2==[ bcT @7 DFA6C:?E6?56?ED :? E96 E@A d__ 5:DEC:4ED 2C6 H@>6?[ 2 ` A6C46?E286 A@:?E :?4C62D6 D:?46 =2DE J62C 2?5 2 e\A@:?E ;F>A D:?46 a_`h] u:7EJ\@?6 @7 E96 ?2E:@?’D H@>6? DFA6C:?E6?56?ED 2C6 2=D@ 2 7:CDE @7 D@>6 <:?5 :? E96:C 5:DEC:4ED — 7:CDE H@>2? DFA6C:?E6?56?E[ 7:CDE q=24< H@>2? @C 7:CDE {2E:?2 DFA6C:?E6?56?E] r2=:7@C?:2 92D E96 >@DE[ H:E9 `` =6256CD H9@ 7:E @?6 @7 E9@D6 56D4C:AE:@?D[ H9:=6 %6I2D 92D D:I]k^Am

kAmx? a_`g[ H96? E96 p=5:?6 x?56A6?56?E $49@@= s:DEC:4E[ ?62C w@FDE@?[ H2D =@@<:?8 7@C 2 ?6H DFA6C:?E6?56?E[ EH@ @7 E96 3@2C5 >6>36CD H2?E65 2 w:DA2?:4 =6256C] (:E9 2 fbT w:DA2?:4 A@AF=2E:@?[ $FA6C:?E6?56?E {2%@?J2 v@77?6J[ H9@ :D q=24<[ F?56CDE@@5 H9J] k^Am

kAm“x 5:5?’E E2<6 :E A6CD@?2==J[” D96 D2:5] “qFE x’G6 366? :?E6?E:@?2= 23@FE 3F:=5:?8 C6=2E:@?D9:AD 2?5 4@??64E:?8 H:E9 E96 4@>>F?:EJ]”k^Am

kAmpD 2?@E96C @?6 @7 E96 fg 5:DEC:4ED E92E 92D <6AE E96 D2>6 =6256C D:?46 E96 A2?56>:4[ k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]9@FDE@?=2?5:?8]@C8^2=5:?6\:D5\92D\DECF88=65\:?\C646?E\J62CD\E96D6\e\492CED\D9@H\9@H^Qmp=5:?6 DECF88=65k^2m >@C6 E92? ?6:893@C:?8 5:DEC:4ED E@ 3@F?46 324< 7C@> 24256>:4 564=:?6D] %@@ >2?J :?6IA6C:6?465 E62496CD H2D @?6 C62D@?[ 2? k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]9@FDE@?=2?5:?8]@C8^?@E\H96C6\H6\H2?E\E@\36\2=5:?6\:D5\DEF56?ED\DE277\DECF88=:?8\F?56C\5:DEC:4E\=6256CD9:A^Qm:?G6DE:82E:@? 7@F?5k^2m] qFE E96 3@2C5 82G6 v@77?6J[ A:4EFC65 36=@H[ >@C6 E:>6 2?5 k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]2=5:?6:D5]@C8^a_aa^`_^`h^2=5:?6\:D5\ECFDE66D\2AAC@G6\4@?EC24E\6IE6?D:@?\7@C\DFA6C:?E6?56?E\5C\=2E@?J2\>\8@77?6J^QmC6?6H65 96C 4@?EC24Ek^2m :? a_aa E9C@F89 ?6IE J62C]k^Am

kAm%96 5:DEC:4E k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]9@FDE@?49C@?:4=6]4@>^AC@;64ED^a_ae^9@FDE@?\5:DEC:4ED\E62\C2E:?8D\36DE\H@CDE^QmDE:== EC2:=D ?6:893@C:?8 DJDE6>Dk^2m :? DE2E6 244@F?E23:=:EJ C2?<:?8D[ 3FE E96 ?F>36C @7 u\C2E65 D49@@=D 92D 72==6? 7C@> a` k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]49C@?]4@>^?6HD^9@FDE@?\E6I2D^65F42E:@?^2CE:4=6^9@FDE@?\D49@@=D\E62\C2E:?8D\aabgggge]A9AQmE@ ak^2m D:?46 a_ab[ 2?5 E96 5:DEC:4E’D @G6C2== D4@C6 :?4C62D65 E9:D J62C 7C@> k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]2=5:?6:D5]@C8^a_ae^_g^`c^2=5:?6\:D5\4@?E:?F6D\E@\2446=6C2E6\24256>:4\8C@HE9\62C?D\7@FCE9\4@?D64FE:G6\J62C\@7\82:?D\:?\E62\244@F?E23:=:EJ\C2E:?8D^Qmfd E@ fhk^2m]k^Am

k7:8FC6mk:>8 DC4lQ9EEADi^^:>286D]DE24<6C]4@>^H^`ag_^:>286D^DE@C:6D^a_ae^`_^b_^$FA6C:?E6?56?E\{2%@?J2\v@77?6J]A?8Q 2=ElQ&?56C p=5:?6[ %6I2D[ $FA6C:?E6?56?E {2%@?J2 v@77?6JUCDBF@jD =6256CD9:A[ E96 ?F>36C @7 u\C2E65 D49@@=D 92D 5C@AA65 7C@> a` E@ a]Q DEJ=6lQH:5E9i `__TQ ^mk7:842AE:@?mr@FCE6DJ @7 p=5:?6 x?56A6?56?E $49@@= s:DEC:4Ek^7:842AE:@?mk^7:8FC6m

kAm$E:==[ :? 2 DE2E6 H96C6 5:DEC:4ED H:E9 =@H\A6C7@C>:?8 D49@@=D 2C6 :?4C62D:?8=J k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]E6I2DEC:3F?6]@C8^a_ae^_g^ad^E6I2D\D49@@=\E2<6@G6CD\:?E6CG6?E:@?\6IA=2:?65^Qm2E C:D< @7 DE2E6 E2<6@G6Ck^2m[ v@77?6J 766=D 4@?DE2?E AC6DDFC6 E@ D9@H DE625J AC@8C6DD] pD 6?C@==>6?E 368:?D E@ 564=:?6 :? E96 DE2E6[ E96 5:DEC:4E D66D 4@>A6E:E:@? ?@E ;FDE 7C@> 492CE6C D49@@=D 2?5 2 ?6H AC:G2E6 D49@@= 49@:46 AC@8C2>[ 3FE 7C@> ?6:893@C:?8 5:DEC:4ED ECJ:?8 E@ “496CCJ A:4<” p=5:?6’D DEF56?ED[ D96 D2:5]k^Am

kAm“|J 7@4FD[ D96 D2:5[ “:D @? >2<:?8 DFC6 E92E p=5:?6 :D E96 36DE 49@:46]”k^Am

kAmk2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]E96fc>:==:@?]@C8^2CE:4=6^6I4=FD:G6\5:DEC:4ED\H:E9\DE625J\=6256CD9:A\D66\36EE6C\DEF56?E\A6C7@C>2?46^Qmk6>m%9:D DE@CJk^6>mk^2mk6>m H2D AC@5F465 3Jk^6>m k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^HHH]E96fc>:==:@?]@C8Qmk6>m%96 fck^6>mk^2mk6>m 2?5 C6G:6H65 2?5 5:DEC:3FE65 3Jk^6>m k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^9F3D]=2^"_b<=8$#_Q C6=lQ?@7@==@HQmk6>m$E24<6Ck^6>mk^2mk6>m]k^6>mk^Am