LEGAL BRIEFS

kAm#@4<6E |@CE8286 92D 7:=65 2 7@C64=@DFC6 =2HDF:E 282:?DE y6C6>J |4|2DE6CD @7 (2=H@CE9 r@F?EJ] |4|2DE6CD >FDE C6DA@?5 H:E9:? c_ 52JD @7 $6AE6>36C ab[ a_ae[ @C C:D< =@D:?8 9:D AC@A6CEJ E@ ;F58>6?E[ =:6?D[ 2?5 82C?:D9>6?E] %96 4@FCE :D =@42E65 2E `g__ r@F?EJ #5 }}[ t=<9@C?[ (x db`a`\`__`] u2:=FC6 E@ C6DA@?5 4@F=5 C6DF=E :? 2FE@>2E:4 ;F58>6?E 282:?DE |4|2DE6CD] {682= 2DD:DE2?46 :D 2G2:=23=6 7C@> r@5:=:D[ |@@5J U2>Aj r:C46==:[ !]r] 2E `d(_b_ }@CE9 uC@?E286 #@25[ $F:E6 a__[ qFCC #:586[ x{ e_daf]k^Am

kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei3@=5Qmv:=6 tDE2E6 rC65:E@C r=2:>D s625=:?6 s64 a`k^DA2?mk^Am

kAm}@E:46 E@ rC65:E@CDi p? 2AA=:42E:@? 7@C :?7@C>2= 25>:?:DEC2E:@? 92D 366? 7:=65 7@C q2C32C2 y] v:=6[ H9@ 5:65 yF?6 ``[ a_ae[ 2?5 H2D 7C@> (2=H@CE9 r@F?EJ] p== :?E6C6DE65 A2CE:6D H2:G65 ?@E:46] %96 5625=:?6 7@C 7:=:?8 4=2:>D 282:?DE 96C 6DE2E6 :D s64] a`[ a_ae] u:=6 4=2:>D 2E E96 (2=H@CE9 r@F?EJ r@FCE9@FD6[ `g__ r@F?EJ #@25 }}[ t=<9@C?[ (x[ #@@> a_gd] pCE@? u] #:K2 :D E96 7@C> 4@>A=6E6Cj 4@?E24E 9:> 2E aea\g`a\_gec]k^Am

kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei3@=5Qm{rq!~p u2== |66E:?8 $F?52J ~4E `` 2E ` !|k^DA2?mk^Am

kAm{@42= r@>@ q6249 !C@A6CEJ ~H?6CD pDD@4:2E:@? W{rq!~pX 2??@F?46D 2 72== >6>36CDV >66E:?8 @? $F?52J[ ~4E@36C ``[ a_ae[ 2E `i__ !| r6?EC2= %:>6[ 2E E96 {rq!~p r=F39@FD6] u@C 7FCE96C 56E2:=D 2?5 FA52E6D[ G:D:E k2 9C67lQ9EEAi^^=2<64@>@36249A@2]4@>Qm=2<64@>@36249A@2]4@>k^2m] %9:D >66E:?8 :D 7@C AC@A6CEJ @H?6CD E@ 5:D4FDD 4@>>F?:EJ :DDF6D[ A=2?D[ 2?5 2?J K@?:?8 492?86D 27764E:?8 E96 2C62] |2C< J@FC 42=6?52CD 2?5 ;@:? J@FC ?6:893@CD 7@C 2? :>A@CE2?E 4@>>F?:EJ 5:D4FDD:@?]k^Am

kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei3@=5QmzC:DE2 w2CG6J $F65j |FDE #6DA@?5 3J ~4E aak^DA2?mk^Am

kAmzC:DE2 w2CG6J 2E bdd w2G6?H@@5 sC:G6[ &?:E `[ {2<6 v6?6G2[ :D 36:?8 DF65 3J y@9? s] |FDE:D] %96 =2HDF:E H2D 7:=65 @? $6AE6>36C ``[ a_ae[ 2?5 D96 >FDE C6DA@?5 3J ~4E@36C aa[ a_ae[ @C C:D< =@D:?8 96C C:89E E@ 4@?E6DE E96 4=2:>] u2:=FC6 E@ C6DA@?5 4@F=5 C6DF=E :? 2FE@>2E:4 ;F58>6?E 282:?DE 96C[ :?4=F5:?8 >@?6J 2H2C5D[ =:6?D @? 96C AC@A6CEJ[ 2?5 2DD6E D6:KFC6] w2CG6J D9@F=5 D6?5 96C HC:EE6? 2?DH6C E@ E96 (2=H@CE9 r@F?EJ r=6C< 2?5 E96 A=2:?E:77VD 2EE@C?6J 3J ~4E@36C aa[ a_ae]k^Am

kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei3@=5Qm{2<6 v6?6G2 ~4E `h |:I65&D6 !=2? w62C:?8k^DA2?mk^Am

kAm{2<6 v6?6G2 C6D:56?ED 2C6 :?G:E65 E@ 2 AF3=:4 962C:?8 @? ~4E@36C `h[ a_ae[ 2E ei__ !| 2E r:EJ w2==[ eae v6?6G2 $EC66E[ C682C5:?8 2 AC@A@D65 >:I65\FD6 56G6=@A>6?E 3J $:>A=6 u@@5 vC@FA {{r @? $96C:52? $AC:?8D #5] %96 A=2? :?G@=G6D AC@A6CE:6D H:E9 %2I z6J }@D] +pcefh____`[ +pcefh____a[ +pceg_____`[ 2?5 +pceg_____a] s6E2:=D @7 E96 2AA=:42E:@? 2C6 2G2:=23=6 7@C :?DA64E:@? 2E r:EJ w2== 5FC:?8 C68F=2C 9@FCD] %9:D 962C:?8 :D 4CF4:2= 7@C E9@D6 :?E6C6DE65 :? E96 4:EJVD 56G6=@A>6?E A=2?D]k^Am

kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei3@=5Qmqrv tBF:E:6D $F6D $E6A96? $>:E9 7@C S`_[___k^DA2?mk^Am

kAmpEE6?E:@? $E6A96? $>:E9 @7 c_d u@I>625 sC[ (2E6C7@C5[ (xi qrv tBF:E:6D[ {{r 92D 7:=65 2 =2HDF:E 282:?DE J@F[ 4=2:>:?8 >@C6 E92? S`_[___] *@F >FDE C6DA@?5 H:E9:? c_ 52JD 7C@> ~4E@36C `[ a_ae[ E@ E96 4@FCE 2E `g__ r@F?EJ #@25 }}[ t=<9@C?[ (x[ 2?5 E@ s{u {2H vC@FA[ {{r[ =@42E65 2E aad $] tI64FE:G6 sC:G6[ qC@@<7:6=5[ (:D4@?D:?] u2:=FC6 E@ C6DA@?5 >2J C6DF=E :? 2 ;F58>6?E 282:?DE J@F] $66< =682= 25G:46]k^Am

kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei3@=5Qm{2<6 v6?6G2 !=2? r@>>:DD:@? w62C:?8 @? ~4E `hk^DA2?mk^Am

kAm%96 {2<6 v6?6G2 !=2? r@>>:DD:@? H:== 9@=5 2 AF3=:4 962C:?8 @? |@?52J[ ~4E@36C `h[ a_ae 2E e A> 2E r:EJ w2==[ eae v6?6G2 $EC66E[ @? 2 r@?5:E:@?2= &D6 !6C>:E 2AA=:42E:@? 3J zFCE y6??:D@?] w6 H2?ED E@ @A6? 2 3:==:2C5 4=F3 2E ffa ( |2:? $EC66E[ 4FCC6?E=J K@?65 rq r6?EC2= qFD:?6DD] %96 2AA=:42E:@? :D 2G2:=23=6 7@C AF3=:4 C6G:6H 2E r:EJ w2== 5FC:?8 C68F=2C @77:46 9@FCD] p== :?E6C6DE65 C6D:56?ED 2C6 :?G:E65 E@ 2EE6?5 2?5 D92C6 E96:C G:6HD]k^Am

kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei3@=5Qm(2=H@CE9 q2C36C $9@A w62C:?8 ~4E `h 2E e !|k^DA2?mk^Am

kAm%96 ':==286 @7 (2=H@CE9[ (x[ H:== 9@=5 2 AF3=:4 962C:?8 @? ~4E@36C `h[ a_ae[ 2E ei__ A]>] :? E96 |F?:4:A2= qF:=5:?8 E@ 4@?D:56C 2 4@?5:E:@?2= FD6 2AA=:42E:@? 3J #2726= yF2C6K U2>Aj *@D6=:? u=@C6D 7@C 2 q2C36C $9@A 2?5 q62FEJ $2=@? 2E ``` $] u:7E9 pG6?F6] %96 !=2? r@>>:DD:@? H:== C6G:6H E96 AC@A@D2= A6C E96 K@?:?8 @C5:?2?46] p== :?E6C6DE65 A2CE:6D >2J 2EE6?5 2?5 G@:46 E96:C @A:?:@?D] s2E65 $6AE6>36C ab[ a_ae[ 3J z6==:6 %96=6?[ r=6C< %C62DFC6C]k^Am

kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei3@=5Qmr@>>:DD:@? E@ w62C yu{ |2C<6E:?8 ~4E `hk^DA2?mk^Am

kAmp AF3=:4 962C:?8 H:== 36 96=5 3J (2=H@CE9 ':==286 !=2? r@>>:DD:@? @? ~4E] `h[ a_ae[ E@ 4@?D:56C yu{ |2C<6E:?8VD 2AA=:42E:@? 7@C 2 4@?5:E:@?2= FD6 7@C 2 =:>:E65 >2?F724EFC:?8 5:DEC:4E 2E c_a }] |2:? $E] %96 >66E:?8 :D 2E e A]>] :? E96 (2=H@CE9 |F?:4:A2= qF:=5:?8[ aaf }] |2:? $E] %96 K@?:?8 492?86 2:>D E@ A6C>:E H2C69@FD:?8[ 5:DEC:3FE:@?[ 2?5 @FE5@@C DE@C286] !F3=:4 :?AFE :D :?G:E65] }@E:46 52E65 $6AE] ab[ a_ae]k^Am

kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei3@=5Qmr@>>:DD:@? E@ r@?D:56C {:BF@C $E@C6 ~4E `hk^DA2?mk^Am

kAm~? ~4E@36C `h[ a_ae[ 2E e A]>][ E96 (2=H@CE9 !=2? r@>>:DD:@? H:== 962C 2? 2AA=:42E:@? 3J w2C>:?56C q92E@J2 W532 #@J2= r6==2CX E@ @A6? 2 =:BF@C DE@C6 2E ``a $] |2:? $E] %96 AF3=:4 42? 2EE6?5 E96 >66E:?8 2E E96 (2=H@CE9 |F?:4:A2= qF:=5:?8[ aaf }] |2:? $E][ E@ G@:46 @A:?:@?D] %9:D 4@F=5 :>A24E =@42= 4@>>6C4:2= K@?:?8 2?5 C6D:56?EDV 2446DD E@ A24<2865 36G6C286 DE@C6D] !F3=:4 :?G@=G6>6?E :D H6=4@>6] s2E65 $6AE6>36C ab[ a_ae]k^Am

kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei3@=5Qm{2<6 v6?6G2 %@ w62C #6DE2FC2?E !=2? ~? ~4E `hk^DA2?mk^Am

kAm%96 r:EJ @7 {2<6 v6?6G2 !=2? r@>>:DD:@? H:== 9@=5 2 AF3=:4 962C:?8 @? ~4E@36C `h[ a_ae[ 2E e !| :? r:EJ w2== E@ 5:D4FDD !24:7:4 !C@A6CEJ w@=5:?8DV A=2? E@ 3F:=5 2 4@>>6C4:2= C6DE2FC2?E @? `c_ qC@25 $E] {@42E65 2E eae v6?6G2 $EC66E[ E96 >66E:?8 :?G:E6D 4@>>F?:EJ >6>36CD E@ 2EE6?5 2?5 G:6H E96 2AA=:42E:@? 2E r:EJ w2== 5FC:?8 C68F=2C 9@FCD] %9:D 56G6=@A>6?E >2J 27764E =@42= 3FD:?6DD 8C@HE9 2?5 4@>>F?:EJ A=2?D]k^Am

kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei3@=5Qm(2=H@CE9 r@F?EJ !2E6C?:EJ w62C:?8 ~4E@36C `bk^DA2?mk^Am

kAmp A2E6C?:EJ 42D6 :? (2=H@CE9 r@F?EJ[ (:D4@?D:?[ D6E 7@C 962C:?8 @? ~4E@36C `b[ a_ae[ 2E aib_ A>[ H:== 36 AC6D:565 @G6C 3J yF586 z6==J xD6=:? 2E E96 (2=H@CE9 r@F?EJ yF5:4:2= r6?E6C] u@C 244@>>@52E:@?D 5F6 E@ 5:D23:=:EJ[ 42== aea\fc`\f_`a 367@C6 E96 52E6] %96 4@FCE 5@6D ?@E AC@G:56 EC2?DA@CE2E:@?] %9:D 962C:?8 4@?46C?D E96 A2E6C?:EJ @7 t]r\#] 2?5 H:== ?@E 36 25;@FC?65 H:E9@FE 7@C>2= >@E:@? @C 2AAC@G2=]k^Am

kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei3@=5QmrC65:E@CDi y6=D49:? tDE2E6 s64 ag[ (:D4@?D:?k^DA2?mk^Am

kAm}@E:46 E@ rC65:E@CDi %96 6DE2E6 @7 (2DD:=: y6=D49:?[ H9@ A2DD65 2H2J @? $6AE6>36C af[ a_ad[ :D :? :?7@C>2= 25>:?:DEC2E:@? :? (2=H@CE9 r@F?EJ[ (:D4@?D:?] %96 5625=:?6 E@ 7:=6 2?J 4=2:>D 282:?DE E96 6DE2E6 :D s646>36C ag[ a_ae] r=2:>D D9@F=5 36 DF3>:EE65 2E E96 (2=H@CE9 r@F?EJ r@FCE9@FD6[ #@@> a_gd[ `g__ r@F?EJ #@25 }}[ t=<9@C?[ (x] p== :?E6C6DE65 A2CE:6D 92G6 H2:G65 ?@E:46] u@C >@C6 56E2:=D[ 4@?E24E 2EE@C?6J s6C6< %] s2C@? 2E Wc`cX c_h\f`aa]k^Am

kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei3@=5Qm!=2? r@>>:DD:@? |66ED ~4E@36C ae pE %@H? w2==k^DA2?mk^Am

kAm~? ~4E@36C ae[ a_ae[ 2E fi__ A]>] :? {:?? %@H? w2==[ E96 !=2? r@>>:DD:@? H:== >66E E@ C6G:6H K@?:?8 2>6?5>6?ED 2?5 G2C:2?46 C6BF6DED[ :?4=F5:?8 2 AF3=:4 962C:?8 7@C y@D6A9 z=:3FC?VD C6BF6DE E@ 3F:=5 C6E2:?:?8 H2==D ?62C v6?6G2 {2<6 2?5 r92C=6D !@==2C5VD C6BF6DE 7@C J2C5 D6E324< G2C:2?46D 7@C 2 ?6H 9@>6] y@:? E96 >66E:?8 :? A6CD@? @C G:2 G:56@ E6=64@?76C6?46j 56E2:=D @? E96 {:?? %@H? w2== H63D:E6] %9:D 27764ED =@42= K@?:?8 =2HD 2?5 AC@A6CEJ 56G6=@A>6?E]k^Am

kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei3@=5QmpF4E:@? ~4E `h |:4926= v@@5D !@EE6CVDk^DA2?mk^Am

kAm~? ~4E@36C `h[ a_ae[ !@EE6CVD $6=7 $E@C286 H:== 2F4E:@? @77 232?5@?65 8@@5D @?=:?6 2E k2 9C67lQ9EEAi^^q:5`b]4@>Qmq:5`b]4@>k^2m] xE6>D :?4=F56 42C A2CED[ E:C6D[ 2 >@E@C4J4=6 =:7E[ 2?5 2 42C DE6C6@ 2>A=:7:6C @H?65 3J |:4926= $ wF>A9C:6D] %96 D2=6 6?5D ~4E@36C ae[ a_ae[ 2E `` 2>] {@42E65 2E (aagd %@H?=:?6 #@25[ {2<6 v6?6G2[ (x[ E96 DE@C286 724:=:EJ 42? 36 C624965 2E WaeaX acg\bddh] %9:D D2=6 :>A24ED 2?J@?6 H9@ =67E :E6>D 2E !@EE6CVD $6=7 $E@C286 2?5 >:DD65 A2J>6?E 5625=:?6D]k^Am

kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei3@=5Qmu@?E2?2 !s w62C:?8 ~4E ae @? p336J r92?86k^DA2?mk^Am

kAm~? |@?52J[ ~4E@36C ae[ a_ae[ 2E di__ A>[ u@?E2?2 ':==286 w2== H:== 9@=5 2 AF3=:4 962C:?8 @? 2 !=2??65 s6G6=@A>6?E p>6?5>6?E AC@A@D65 3J r2CJ z6C86CVD p336J !C@G:56?E '6?EFC6 {{r] %96 >66E:?8 D66<D AF3=:4 E6DE:>@?J @? E96 2>6?5>6?E E@ ~C5:?2?46 }@] _badac\_a 7@C A2C46=D $pd`cb____c E@ $#v{ ___`h] s6E2:=D 2C6 :? E96 2AA=:42E:@? 2G2:=23=6 2E E96 ':==286 w2== @C G:2 6>2:= E@ k2 9C67lQ>2:=E@iG:==2864=6C<oG:QmG:==2864=6C<oG:k^2m] k2 9C67lQ9EEAi^^7@?E2?2]H:]8@GQm7@?E2?2]H:]8@Gk^2m] %9:D 4@F=5 :>A24E =@42= 56G6=@A>6?E A=2?D 2?5 4@>>F?:EJ 8C@HE9]k^Am

kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei3@=5Qmu@?E2?2 $49@@= !C@;64E w62C:?8 ~4E aek^DA2?mk^Am

kAm#6D:56?ED @7 u@?E2?2[ (:D4@?D:?[ H:== 92G6 2 492?46 E@ G@:46 E96:C @A:?:@?D @? 2 4@?5:E:@?2= FD6 A6C>:E 7@C 2 u@?E2?2 $49@@= s:DEC:4E AC@;64E 2E 2 AF3=:4 962C:?8 @? ~4E@36C ae[ a_ae[ 2E di__ A> :? u@?E2?2 ':==286 w2==] $E6G6 %@CC6K :D D66<:?8 2AAC@G2= 7@C :?5@@C :?DE:EFE:@?2= FD6 2E cd_ $ |2:? $E] %96 962C:?8 H:== 2==@H AF3=:4 E6DE:>@?J[ 2?5 5@4F>6?ED 2C6 2G2:=23=6 2E E96 G:==286 92== @C G:2 6>2:= 7C@> E96 G:==286 4=6C<] %9:D 4@F=5 :>A24E =@42= K@?:?8 2?5 6?G:C@?>6?E2= A@=:4:6D]k^Am

kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei3@=5Qmt5H2C5 s62? $66<D !:6C !6C>:E #6G:6Hk^DA2?mk^Am

kAmt5H2C5 s62? D66<D 2 A6C>:E 7C@> E96 (:D4@?D:? s}# E@ 6IE6?5 2?5 C@E2E6 2 A:6C @? v6?6G2 {2<6 :? {:??[ (2=H@CE9 r@F?EJ] %96 AF3=:4 42? C6G:6H A=2?D 2?5 DF3>:E 4@>>6?ED G:2 6>2:= @C >2:= 3J b_ 52JD 27E6C ?@E:46 AF3=:42E:@?] p AF3=:4 962C:?8 42? 36 C6BF6DE65 H:E9:? a_ 52JD] %96 s6A2CE>6?E A=2?D E@ :DDF6 E96 A6C>:E :7 E96 AC@;64E >66ED 2== C6BF:C6>6?ED] ':D:E k2 9C67lQ9EEADi^^A6C>:ED]5?C]H:]8@G^H2E6C^Qm9EEADi^^A6C>:ED]5?C]H:]8@G^H2E6C^k^2m $:E6!286D^!6C>:ETa_$62C49]2DAI 7@C >@C6 56E2:=D]k^Am

kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei3@=5Qm$F>>:E $F6D y@?6D x? (2=H@CE9 r@FCE r2D6k^DA2?mk^Am

kAm$F>>:E rC65:E &?:@? 92D 7:=65 2 =2HDF:E 282:?DE #J2? t] y@?6D :? (2=H@CE9 r@F?EJ r:C4F:E r@FCE Wr2D6 }@] aer'df_X] %96 5676?52?E >FDE C6DA@?5 H:E9 2 HC:EE6? 56>2?5 7@C E96 4@>A=2:?E H:E9:? c_ 52JD @7 ~4E@36C f[ a_ae[ E@ 2G@:5 5672F=E ;F58>6?E] u2:=FC6 E@ C6DA@?5 >2J C6DF=E :? 2 =:6? @? 2?J C62= 6DE2E6 @H?65[ 82C?:D9>6?E[ @C AC@A6CEJ D6:KFC6] %96 56>2?5 D9@F=5 36 D6?E E@ E96 (2=H@CE9 r@F?EJ r=6C< @7 r@FCED 2?5 E96 A=2:?E:77VD 2EE@C?6J[ yFDE:? y] q2E6D 2E !~ q@I `cfb[ (2FD2F[ (x dcc_a]k^Am

kAmkDA2? DEJ=6lQ7@?E\H6:89Ei3@=5Qmq=@@>7:6=5 $66<D q:5D 7@C ((%! #@@7[ ~4E abk^DA2?mk^Am

kAm%96 ':==286 @7 q=@@>7:6=5 :? (:D4@?D:? D66<D 3:5D 7@C E96 C@@7 C6A=246>6?E 2E :ED H2DE6H2E6C EC62E>6?E A=2?E W((%!X] $62=65 3:5D 2C6 5F6 3J ~4E@36C abC5 2E `_i__ 2> 2E ':==286 w2== @? }``__ %@H? w2== #@25] q:55:?8 5@4F>6?ED 4@DE Sbd 2?5 2C6 5@H?=@2523=6 G:2 k2 9C67lQ9EEAi^^HHH]BF6DE45?]4@>QmHHH]BF6DE45?]4@>k^2m FD:?8 !C@;64E R`_bh_``d] q:5D >FDE :?4=F56 2 dT 3@?5] %96 G:==286 >2J C6;64E 2?J 3:5D 2?5 H:== 2H2C5 E96 4@?EC24E E@ E96 =@H6DE BF2=:7:65 3:556C] u@C BF6DE:@?D[ C6249 @FE E@ k2 9C67lQ9EEAi^^"F6DErs}]4@>Qm"F6DErs}]4@>k^2m]k^Am

kAm{682= qC:67D 2C6 4@?56?D65 DF>>2C:6D @7 AF3=:4 ?@E:46D AF3=:D965 :? E9:D 65:E:@?] %96D6 DF>>2C:6D 2C6 86?6C2E65 FD:?8 2CE:7:4:2= :?E6==:86?46 2?5 2C6 AC@G:565 7@C C6256C 4@?G6?:6?46 @?=J] #6256CD D9@F=5 C6G:6H E96 4@>A=6E6 @C:8:?2= =682= ?@E:46D :? E@52JVD AF3=:42E:@? @C H:E9:? E96 6\65:E:@? 7@C 7F== 56E2:=D W2G2:=23=6 :? >@DE >2C<6EDX]k^Am