Food recalls explained: Why it seems like food contamination is on the rise
From eggs to Honey Smacks and pre-cut melon, the food products recalled during the past few weeks could make shoppers queasy with worry about whether what they've just picked up from the grocery store is riddled with potentially harmful pathogens.
This year, salmonella has been the headliner, with the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention reporting eight food-related outbreaks since January. (Remember raw sprouts, frozen shredded coconut and chicken salad?)
Is the number of contaminated foods increasing?
No. Experts say it's not food-borne contaminants that have increased. It's that the ability to detect them has improved.
Are recalls getting more frequent?
Government agencies such as local and state health departments, the Food and Drug Administration, the USDA's Food and Safety Inspection Service and the CDC are using better technology to identify, track and contain outbreaks. The FDA oversees all food inspection programs. Meat, poultry, dairy and produce are regulated by the Agriculture Department. Once produce is processed into something like apple juice or banana chips, it is also regulated by the FDA.
Then why are we hearing about more outbreaks?
"The interesting thing about these bacteria is that they mutate very quickly, which is a great thing for disease detectives," said Jory Lange, a Houston-based attorney who specializes in food safety cases. "Because of that rapid mutation, there's a genetic fingerprint that makes it easier to trace."
But that doesn't mean authorities necessarily know the full extent of a problem. For every one reported case, there are 20 unreported ones, Lange said.
"The reason that's so concerning (is that) without identifying the problem, we can't fix it," he said. "If we can't fix the problem, then we may have someone get sick next month."
Can a food be immune from problems?
There's no way to produce an absolutely safe food, experts say. But consumers can be more diligent about cooking meat to the recommended temperatures, keeping their hands and food preparation spaces clean, refrigerating food and being careful not to not cross-contaminate raw meat and poultry with ready-to-eat food.
How are changing food preferences factoring into the problem?
Decades ago, the path from farm to kitchen table was much shorter and more local. Today, food that at one time wasn't available in certain seasons now is, making the path to consumer's tables longer, more complicated and rife with opportunities for contamination. Also, consumers are demanding a greater variety of easier-to-prepare and ready-to-eat foods that despite being fresh, have a longer road to the grocery store.
Out-of-season produce
Take, for example, out-of-season packaged, pre-washed produce. It's gone through several steps - from the field to the processor, the packager, the distributor and then the grocer, with the possibility of contamination at each step.
"Fifty years ago you would have gotten lettuce from a farmer in your state, now it's coming from California and Arizona on a much larger scale," said Matthew Jon Stasiewicz, an assistant professor of applied food safety at the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign.Â
How distance and scale factor in
It's not just coming from farther away, it's coming from fewer and larger distributors.
"When you get food on a larger scale it's not inherently any riskier, but if there's a problem the potential harm is magnified," Stasiewicz said.Â
What tools are experts using to better track outbreaks and contain them?
Tracing the food's path to the consumer's mouth is an active area of research. Traditionally, a foodborne illness diagnosis (determined by a stool sample) is reported to local and state health departments that work with the CDC try to drill down to the source of the pathogen.
"Genome sequencing"
Increasingly, experts are using a tool called "genome sequencing," which uses the DNA fingerprint of the food to help determine its source. A national database at the CDC known as PulseNet uses that DNA fingerprint to link illnesses to one another and try to determine the source of the outbreak.
Tracking your food
The challenge is that experts can't narrow down exactly where the contamination began - the field, the packing and processing plants or the grocery store. New technologies are being developed to make it easier and quicker to track food from the field to the grocery store.
Can foodborne illness outbreaks be deadly?
Yes. The romaine lettuce outbreak that began last year has hospitalized 89 people and killed five since it was first reported by the CDC in April.
Are there laws to force food producers to better handle and avoid contaminating foods?
Yes. The Food Safety Modernization Act, enacted in 2011, requires food producers to create better safety measures. But some experts say it's not comprehensive. "We have not implemented a system that allows us to trace back to the farm level," said Jaydee Hanson, senior policy analyst at the Center for Food Safety.Â
"One plant and one fruit ..."
Currently companies are only required to report where they obtained a food product and the customer for their product, not the entire distribution process.
"Food is something that can get contaminated at any step of the process," said Lange. "One plant and one fruit ... if you have a problem, that problem can spread."Â
The two are charged with three counts of attempted first-degree intentional homicide and aggravated battery, among other charges.
