Reality of ban on transgender athletes competing is nuanced

kAm%CF>A C6G:D:E65 E96 E@A:4 >F=E:A=6 E:>6D :? E96 >@?E9D 2?5 H66<D 367@C6 E96 6=64E:@?[ DF886DE:?8 2E 9:D C2==:6D E92E @?6 @7 E96 8@2=D @7 9:D D64@?5 E6C> H@F=5 36 E@ Q<66A >6? @FE @7 H@>6?VD DA@CED]Q |:==:@?D H6C6 DA6?E @? 25G6CE:D:?8 E92E EFC?65 D@>6E9:?8 E92E 27764ED 2 E:?J >:?@C:EJ @7 4@>A6E:E@CD :?E@ 2 H6586 :DDF6]k^Am

kAm|@C6 E92? 92=7 @7 G@E6CD @G6C2== — 2?5 E96 G2DE >2;@C:EJ @7 %CF>A DFAA@CE6CD — D2:5 DFAA@CE 7@C EC2?D86?56C C:89ED :? 8@G6C?>6?E 2?5 D@4:6EJ 92D 8@?6 E@@ 72C[ 244@C5:?8 E@ p! '@E6r2DE[ 2 DFCG6J @7 >@C6 E92? `a_[___ G@E6CD ?2E:@?H:56]k^Am

kAm(92E[ 6I24E=J[ %CF>A H:== 5@ H96? 96 E2<6D @77:46 @? y2?] a_ :D F?4=62C] w:D EC2?D:E:@? E62> 92D ?@E 5:GF=865 2?J DA64:7:4D[ E9@F89 E96 AC6D:56?E\6=64E D2:5 5FC:?8 9:D 42>A2:8? E92E E96 AC@46DD H@F=5 36 Q62DJ]Qk^Am

kAmx? D@>6 H2JD[ :E >:89E 36] x? @E96CD[ E9:?8D 4@F=5 36 72C >FC<:6C]k^Am

k9bm(92E 5:5 %CF>A D2J 5FC:?8 E96 42>A2:8?nk^9bm

kAmp =@E] %CF>A D66>65 E@ :56?E:7J E96 5:D4FDD:@? 2C@F?5 E96 C:89ED @7 EC2?D86?56C A6@A=6 :? 86?6C2= 2?5 EC2?D 2E9=6E6D :? A2CE:4F=2C 2D @?6 E92E 4@F=5 82C?6C 3@E9 2EE6?E:@? 2?5 DFAA@CE E92E H6?E 36J@?5 9:D FDF2= 32D6]k^Am

kAm%CF>A H@F=5 @7E6? FD6 =2?8F286 23@FE 86?56C :56?E:EJ E92E {vq%"Z 25G@42E6D D2J :D HC@?8 2?5 92C>7F=] w6 2=D@ 72=D6=J =236=65 EH@ ~=J>A:4 76>2=6 3@I6CD 2D >6?[ 2?5 D2:5 E96:C 23:=:EJ E@ A2CE:4:A2E6 :? E96 !2C:D v2>6D H2D Q56>62?:?8 E@ H@>6?Q 6G6? E9@F89 3@E9 x>2?6 z96=:7 @7 p=86C:2 2?5 {: *F\E:?8 @7 %2:H2? H6C6 2DD:8?65 76>2=6 2E 3:CE9 2?5 :56?E:7J 2D H@>6?]k^Am

kAm%CF>A C2>A65 FA E96 C96E@C:4 2D 6=64E:@? 52J 2AAC@24965[ E6==:?8 E96 4C@H5 2E 2 |25:D@? $BF2C6 v2C56? C2==J :? ~4E@36Ci Q(6 H:== 86E ]]] EC2?D86?56C :?D2?:EJ E96 96== @FE @7 @FC D49@@=D[ 2?5 H6 H:== <66A >6? @FE @7 H@>6?VD DA@CED]Qk^Am

k9bm(92E 2C6 E96 AC6D:56?E:2= A@H6CD :? E9:D 2C62nk^9bm

kAm%CF>A 92D D2:5 @? s2J ` E92E 96 H@F=5 4FE 7656C2= 7F?5:?8 E@ Q2?J D49@@= AFD9:?8 4C:E:42= C246 E96@CJ[ EC2?D86?56C :?D2?:EJ[ 2?5 @E96C :?2AAC@AC:2E6 C24:2=[ D6IF2= @C A@=:E:42= 4@?E6?E @? @FC 49:=5C6?]Qk^Am

kAm%96C6 2C6 D6G6C2= =2J6CD E@ E9:D[ 3FE E96 >@DE :>>65:2E6 H@F=5 36 9@H 9:D 25>:?:DEC2E:@? :?E6CAC6ED %:E=6 x)[ E96 =2H 36DE <?@H? 7@C :ED C@=6 :? AFCDF:?8 86?56C 6BF:EJ :? 2E9=6E:4D 2?5 AC6G6?E:?8 D6IF2= 92C2DD>6?E @? 42>AFD6D]k^Am

kAmtG6CJ 25>:?:DEC2E:@? 92D E96 2FE9@C:EJ E@ :DDF6 :ED @H? :?E6CAC6E2E:@?D @7 E96 =2?5>2C< =68:D=2E:@?] %96 =2DE EH@ AC6D:56?E:2= 25>:?:DEC2E:@?D — :?4=F5:?8 %CF>AVD 7:CDE — @776C 2 8=:>AD6 2E E96 AFD9\AF== :?G@=G65]k^Am

kAmq6EDJ s6'@D[ E96 65F42E:@? D64C6E2CJ 5FC:?8 %CF>AVD 7:CDE E6C>[ :DDF65 2 %:E=6 x) A@=:4J :? a_a_ E92E ?2CC@H65 E96 567:?:E:@? @7 D6IF2= 92C2DD>6?E 2?5 C6BF:C65 4@==686D E@ :?G6DE:82E6 4=2:>D @?=J :7 E96JVC6 C6A@CE65 E@ 46CE2:? @77:4:2=D]k^Am

kAm%96 q:56? 25>:?:DEC2E:@? C@==65 324< E92E A@=:4J :? pAC:= H:E9 @?6 @7 :ED @H? E92E DE:AF=2E65 E96 C:89ED @7 {vq%"Z DEF56?ED H@F=5 36 AC@E64E65 3J 7656C2= =2H 2?5 AC@G:565 ?6H D2768F2C5D 7@C G:4E:>D @7 42>AFD D6IF2= 2DD2F=E] %96 A@=:4J DE@AA65 D9@CE @7 6IA=:4:E=J 255C6DD:?8 EC2?D86?56C 2E9=6E6D] $E:==[ >@C6 E92? 2 92=7\5@K6? #6AF3=:42?\=65 DE2E6D :>>65:2E6=J 492==6?865 E96 ?6H CF=6 :? 4@FCE]k^Am

kAm%CF>A 4@F=5 282:? D9:7E E96 H2J E96 %:E=6 x) DA@CED C68F=2E:@? :D G:6H65 2?5 6?7@C465]k^Am

kAmQp== %CF>A 92D E@ D2J :D[ V(6 2C6 8@:?8 E@ C625 E96 C68F=2E:@? EC25:E:@?2==J[VQ D2:5 s@C:2?6 {2>36=6E r@=6>2?[ 2 AC@76DD@C 2E sF<6 {2H $49@@=]k^Am

k9bm(92EVD E96 5:776C6?46 36EH66? QD6IQ 2?5 Q86?56CQ 2?5 9@H H@F=5 :E 27764E %:E=6 x)nk^9bm

kAm&?56C E96 7:CDE %CF>A 25>:?:DEC2E:@?[ E96 8@G6C?>6?E :?E6CAC6E65 QD6IQ 2D E96 86?56C D@>6@?6 H2D 2DD:8?65 2E 3:CE9]k^Am

kAm%96 q:56? 25>:?:DEC2E:@? 49@D6 E@ :?E6CAC6E D6I 2D Q86?56C :56?E:EJQ F?56C %:E=6 x)[ H9:49 4@F=5 36 :?E6CAC6E65 E@ AC@E64E EC2?D 2E9=6E6D 7C@> 36:?8 5:D4C:>:?2E65 282:?DE :7 E96J H2?E65 E@ A2CE:4:A2E6 :? 2 DA@CE E92E 2=:8?65 H:E9 E96:C 86?56C :56?E:EJ[ ?@E E96:C D6I 2DD:8?65 2E 3:CE9]k^Am

kAmxE :D H:56=J 6IA64E65 E92E %CF>A H:== C@== 324< E96 567:?:E:@? @7 D6I E@ 2=:8? H:E9 E96 D6I D@>6@?6 H2D 2DD:8?65 2E 3:CE9]k^Am

k9bmw@H >2?J EC2?D86?56C 2E9=6E6D 2C6 24E:G6=J 4@>A6E:?8nk^9bm

kAm%92E ?F>36C :D FA 7@C 5632E6]k^Am

kAm%96 }rpp[ 7@C 6I2>A=6[ 5@6D ?@E EC24< 52E2 @? EC2?D86?56C 2E9=6E6D 2>@?8 E96 dcc[___ 4FCC6?E=J 4@>A6E:?8 @? `h[___ E62>D 2E G2C:@FD =6G6=D 24C@DD E96 4@F?ECJ[ E9@F89 }rpp AC6D:56?E r92C=:6 q2<6C E6DE:7:65 :? r@?8C6DD @? %F6D52J E92E 96 H2D 2H2C6 @7 =6DD E92? `_ 24E:G6 }rpp 2E9=6E6D H9@ :56?E:7:65 2D EC2?D86?56C]k^Am

kAmp a_`h DFCG6J @7 9:89 D49@@= DEF56?ED 3J E96 v2J[ {6D3:2? 2?5 $EC2:89E t5F42E:@? }6EH@C< Wv{$t}X ?@E65 ;FDE dT @7 C6DA@?56?ED D2:5 E96J A2CE:4:A2E65 :? 2 DA@CE E92E 2=:8?65 H:E9 E96:C 86?56C :56?E:EJ]k^Am

kAmxE >:89E 36 62D:6C E@ 5@ E96 >2E9 7C@> 2 >24C@ =6G6=] p a_aa C6A@CE 3J E96 (:==:2>D x?DE:EFE6 6DE:>2E65 23@FE b__[___ 9:89 D49@@=\286 DEF56?ED W`b\`fX :56?E:7:65 2D EC2?D86?56C] w@H >2?J @7 E9@D6 J@F?8 A6@A=6 A2CE:4:A2E6 :? DA@CED :D F?<?@H?[ 3FE :E :D =:<6=J 2 E:?J 7C24E:@?]k^Am

kAm$E:==[ 2?J 42D6 @7 2 EC2?D86?56C 2E9=6E6 4@>A6E:?8 — @C 6G6? 36=:6G65 E@ 36 4@>A6E:?8 — 5C2HD @FED:K65 2EE6?E:@?[ 7C@> {:2 %9@>2D DH:>>:?8 7@C E96 &?:G6CD:EJ @7 !6??DJ=G2?:2 E@ E96 ;FDE\4@>A=6E65 D62D@? @7 E96 $2? y@D6 $E2E6 G@==6J32== E62>]k^Am

k9bm(92E 2C6 E96 CF=6D 2E E96 9:89 D49@@= =6G6=nk^9bm

kAmxE G2C:6D 7C@> DE2E6 E@ DE2E6] p3@FE 92=7 E96 DE2E6D 92G6 6?24E65 =68:D=2E:@? E92E 67764E:G6=J 32CD EC2?D86?56C 2E9=6E6D 7C@> 4@>A6E:?8 :? E96 42E68@CJ E92E 2=:8?D H:E9 E96:C 86?56C :56?E:EJ]k^Am

kAm%96 p! C6A@CE65 :? a_a` E92E :? >2?J 42D6D[ E96 DE2E6D :?EC@5F4:?8 2 32? @? EC2?D86?56C 2E9=6E6D 4@F=5 ?@E 4:E6 :?DE2?46D H96C6 E96:C A2CE:4:A2E:@? H2D 2? :DDF6] (96? &E29 DE2E6 =68:D=2E@CD @G6CC@56 2 G6E@ 3J v@G] $A6?46C r@I :? a_aa[ E96 DE2E6 925 @?=J @?6 EC2?D86?56C 8:C= A=2J:?8 :? z\`a DA@CED H9@ H@F=5 36 27764E65 3J E96 32?] xE 5:5 ?@E C68F=2E6 A2CE:4:A2E:@? 7@C EC2?D86?56C 3@JD]k^Am

kAmQ%9:D :D 2 D@=FE:@? =@@<:?8 7@C 2 AC@3=6>[Q D2:5 r96CJ= r@@<J[ 2 AC@76DD@C 2E !FC5F6 &?:G6CD:EJ H9@ DEF5:6D E96 :?E6CD64E:@? @7 86?56C[ DA@CED[ >65:2 2?5 4F=EFC6]k^Am

k9bm(92E 23@FE 4@==68:2E6=Jnk^9bm

kAm%96 }rpp 6DE23=:D965 2 A@=:4J :? a_`_ E92E C6BF:C6D EC2?D 2E9=6E6D H9@ H6C6 2DD:8?65 >2=6 2E 3:CE9 E@ 4@>A=6E6 2E =62DE @?6 J62C @7 E6DE@DE6C@?6 DFAAC6DD:@? E96C2AJ 367@C6 36:?8 6=:8:3=6 E@ 4@>A6E6 @? 2 H@>6?VD E62>] %C2?D 2E9=6E6D H9@ H6C6 2DD:8?65 76>2=6 2E 3:CE9 2?5 EC2?D:E:@?65 E@ >2=6 42? 4@>A6E6 @? 2 >6?VD E62>[ 3FE :7 E96J 92G6 C646:G65 E6DE@DE6C@?6 EC62E>6?E E96J 2C6 :?6=:8:3=6 E@ 4@>A6E6 @? 2 H@>6?VD E62>]k^Am

kAm%96 2E9=6E6D 2C6 C6BF:C65 E@ >66E E96:C 49@D6? DA@CEVD DE2?52C5 7@C 5@4F>6?E65 E6DE@DE6C@?6 =6G6=D 2E G2C:@FD A@:?ED 5FC:?8 2 D62D@?]k^Am

kAmx? a_aa[ E96 }rpp C6G:D65 E96 A@=:4J :? H92E E96 @C82?:K2E:@? 42==65 2? 2EE6>AE E@ 36 2=:8?65 H:E9 ?2E:@?2= DA@CED 8@G6C?:?8 3@5:6D W}vqDX] x7 E96 }vq 5@6D ?@E 92G6 2 EC2?D 2E9=6E6 A@=:4J[ E96? :E D42=6D FA E@ E96 :?E6C?2E:@?2= 7656C2E:@? E92E @G6CD66D E96 DA@CE] x7 E96C6 :D ?@ :?E6C?2E:@?2= 7656C2E:@? A@=:4J[ AC6G:@FD=J 6DE23=:D965 ~=J>A:4 A@=:4J 4C:E6C:2 H@F=5 36 7@==@H65]k^Am

kAm%96 }rppVD 564:D:@? E@ <:4< :E FA E@ E96 }vqD AC@G65 >@C6 C6DEC:4E:G6 :? D@>6 DA@CED =:<6 DH:>>:?8] p A@=:4J :?EC@5F465 3J (@C=5 pBF2E:4D :? a_ab @?=J 2==@HD EC2?D86?56C 2E9=6E6D E@ 4@>A6E6 :? H@>6?VD C246D :7 E96 2E9=6E6 42? AC@G6 E96J 92G6 ?@E 6IA6C:6?465 2?J A2CE @7 >2=6 AF36CEJ]k^Am

kAm%9:?8D 2C6 72C >@C6 567:?:E:G6 7@C D49@@=D E92E 4@>A6E6 :? E96 }2E:@?2= pDD@4:2E:@? @7 x?E6C4@==68:2E6 pE9=6E:4D[ E96 8@G6C?:?8 3@5J 7@C >@C6 E92? a__ D>2== D49@@=D 24C@DD E96 4@F?ECJ] %96 }pxp G@E65 F?2?:>@FD=J 62C=:6C E9:D J62C E@ 67764E:G6=J 32? EC2?D86?56C 2E9=6E6D 7C@> 4@>A6E:?8 :? H@>6?VD DA@CED]k^Am

k9bmp?5 9@H 23@FE E96 ~=J>A:4 =6G6=nk^9bm

kAm%96 x?E6C?2E:@?2= ~=J>A:4 r@>>:EE66 92D 6DD6?E:2==J A2DD65 E96 3F4<[ 5676CC:?8 E@ E96 :?E6C?2E:@?2= 7656C2E:@?D 7@C 6249 DA@CE]k^Am

kAm%92E 4@F=5 492?86[ 9@H6G6C[ H96? 2 ?6H x~r AC6D:56?E 4@>6D @? E@ C6A=246 E96 C6E:C:?8 %9@>2D q249]k^Am

kAmu@C>6C EC24< DE2C $632DE:2? r@6[ ?@H E96 =6256C @7 (@C=5 pE9=6E:4D[ :D 2>@?8 E96 42?5:52E6D FA 7@C 6=64E:@? :? |2C49] r@6 92D 366? 2 DEC@?8 AC@A@?6?E @7 =:>:E:?8 A2CE:4:A2E:@? E@ 4:D86?56C H@>6?]k^Am

k9bm(92E >:89E E96 7FEFC6 =@@< =:<6nk^9bm

kAm%96 ?62C 7FEFC6 7:8FC6D E@ 36 G@=2E:=6[ H:E9 E96 DE2E6\3J\DE2E6 >2A @? EC2?D86?56C 2E9=6E6D >:CC@C:?8 H92E 23@CE:@? 2446DD =@@<D =:<6 A@DE\s@33D] s6>@4C2ED 92G6 366? 2E @55D 23@FE 9@H E@ 255C6DD E96 E@A:4]k^Am

kAm%96C6 :D 2 492?46 E92E 2 #6AF3=:42?\=65 r@?8C6DD 4@F=5 :?EC@5F46 2?@E96C 7@C> @7 E96 Q!C@E64E:@? @7 (@>6? 2?5 v:C=D :? $A@CED p4EQ E92E H2D AC@A@D65 :? a_a` 2?5 a_ab] %96 a_ab G6CD:@? @7 E96 3:== — H9:49 H@F=5 AC@9:3:E D49@@= 2E9=6E:4 AC@8C2>D 7C@> 2==@H:?8 :?5:G:5F2=D H9@D6 3:@=@8:42= D6I 2E 3:CE9 H2D >2=6 E@ A2CE:4:A2E6 :? AC@8C2>D E92E 2C6 7@C H@>6? @C 8:C=D — A2DD65 E96 w@FD6 3FE 5:5?VE >2<6 :E E@ E96 $6?2E6 7=@@C 7@C 2 G@E6]k^Am

kAm#6AF3=:42?D 9@=5 2 D=:> >2;@C:EJ :? E96 $6?2E6 2?5 C6>2:? D9@CE @7 E96 e_\G@E6 E9C6D9@=5 ?66565 7@C A2DD286[ 3FE 8:G6? E96 H9:E6\9@E 5:D4FDD:@? 2C@F?5 EC2?D86?56C 2E9=6E6D E96 :DDF6 4@F=5 4@>6 E@ E96 7@C6 BF:4<=J] xE 4@F=5 4@>6 6G6? 2D $2C29 |4qC:56[ 2 s6>@4C2E 7C@> |2CJ=2?5[ 364@>6D E96 7:CDE @A6?=J EC2?D86?56C A6CD@? :? r@?8C6DD]k^Am

kAmk6>mp! $A@CED (C:E6C vC292> sF?32C 4@?EC:3FE65 E@ E9:D C6A@CE]k^6>mk^Am