First place: Herner's Hideaway, N202 Williams Rd, Genoa City
Hometown favorites: Papa’s Blue Spruce Resort
Breaking Alert Top Story
The best fish fries in Walworth County, plus best burger, best Italian and more
Looking for a new place to try? Check out the favorites that area residents voted the best restaurants around Geneva Lake. Here is your list for 2022 from the Lake Geneva Regional News' Best of Geneva Lake.Â
The categories were all voted on by local visitors and residents.Â
Best burger
Best fish fry
First place: Herner's Hideaway, N202 Williams Rd, Genoa City
Hometown favorite: Mars Resort
Best steaks around Geneva Lake
First place: Jonathan's on Brick Street, 116 E Walworth Ave, Delavan
Hometown favorites: Anthony's Steakhouse & Seafood
Best Wait Staff/servers around Geneva Lake
First place: Jonathan's on Brick Street, 116 E Walworth Ave, Delavan
Hometown favorites: Next Door Pub & Pizzeria
Best seafood
First place: Jonathan's on Brick Street, 116 E Walworth Ave, Delavan
Hometown favorite: Geneva Chophouse
Best Wine Selection (Non-Retail)
Head to The Big Taste End of Summer Gala at Lake Geneva’s The Bottle Shop.
First place: The Bottle Shop, 617 W Main St, Lake Geneva
Hometown favorite: Jonathan's on Brick Street
Best sandwich shop
First place: Herner's Hideaway, N202 Williams Rd, Genoa City
Hometown favorite: Green Grocer & Deli
Best pizza
Next Door Pub & Pizzeria, 411 Interchange N., Lake Geneva.
First place: Next Door Pub & Pizzeria, 411 Interchange N, Lake Geneva
Hometown favorite: Little Bar
Best Mexican restaurant
31 N Wisconsin St., ElkhornÂ
First place: Los Tres Hermanos, 31 N Wisconsin St, Elkhorn
Hometown favorite: Taqueria El Gallo De Oro
Best Italian restaurant
The 2-acre property where Café Calamari and Harpoon Willies is now located along the lake in Williams Bay could be developed in the future. Bu…
First place: Cafè Calamari, 10 E Geneva St, Williams Bay
Hometown favorite: Rigatony's
Best ice cream
Kilwins Chocolates in Lake Geneva
First place: Kilwins Lake Geneva, 772 W Main St, Lake Geneva
Hometown favorite: Meggy Moo's Dairy Ripple
Best fine dining
First place: Jonathan's on Brick Street, 116 E Walworth Ave, Delavan
Hometown favorite: Opus at The Belfry House
Watch now: Kitesurfing on Geneva Lake
Best date night spot
First place: Jonathan's on Brick Street, 116 E Walworth Ave, Delavan
Hometown favorite: Magpie's Den & Pen
Best coffee shop
Jessie Bongiorno, general manager for Inspired Coffee, from left, and training development coordinators Lisa Slattery-Brochtrup and Ryn Chavez…
First place: Inspired, 883 W Main St, Lake Geneva
Hometown favorite: Boxed and Burlap
Best cocktails
First place: Herner's Hideaway, N202 Williams Rd, Genoa City
Hometown favorites: Kimkasi Pub
Best brewery
First place: Topsy Turvy Brewery, 727 Geneva St, Lake Geneva
Hometown favorite: Duesterbeck's Brewing Company
Watch now: Geneva shore path Fontana to Black Point
Best breakfast/brunch
First place: Grandma Vickie's Cafe, 522 Broad St, Lake Geneva
Hometown favorite: Simple Café
Best bloody mary
First place: Herner's Hideaway, N202 Williams Rd, Genoa City
Hometown favorite: Papa’s Blue Spruce Resort
Best beer selection (non-retail)
First place: Herner's Hideaway, N202 Williams Rd, Genoa City
Hometown favorite: Flat Iron Tap
Best bar food
First place: Next Door Pub & Pizzeria, 411 Interchange N, Lake Geneva
Hometown favorite: Herner's Hideaway
Best banquet space
Boxed and Burlap, located in Delavan at 2935 WI-67, is shown in a Google Maps image captured June 2019. Owner John Neighbors is seeking approv…
First place: Boxed and Burlap, 2935 WI-67, Delavan
Hometown favorite: Hawk's View Golf Club
Best Asian restaurant
Sabai Sabai in Lake Geneva
First place: Sabai Sabai Thai & Sushi restaurant, 306 Center St, Lake Geneva
Hometown favorite: Two Sisters Thai
Prepare to gobble and wobble this weekend.
Looking for a new place to try? Check out the favorites that area residents voted the best restaurants around Geneva Lake. Here is your list f…
Geneva Lake Environmental Agency plans to purchase boat cleaning machines for lakefront communities
